A question that works my mind since I came here. As of now I have to say NO and as much as I agree to Ceilia Waldens article in the telegraph I have a few points against it. Let me list them here and as always they are up for discussion. Make sure to read Ceilias excellent article. I could have not written it better :-)

So why is Moscow (still) not the new New York? Moscow is lacking enough sub-cultures and the underground. There is this huge creative scene that generated so much music and art in New York and that makes out the real New York. Moreover its fueled by the mulit-culti mix that Moscow is lacking. Sure, you have a lot of middle Eastern and Caucasian people in Moscow. Mix that with a few African students and the expat community and you can call Moscow somewhat a Metropolitan city with multiple cultures, but its far from New York. Of course Ceilias article was focused on the nightlife, but even in that sense we are missing what makes New York such a special city.

The ever growing middle class breeds a few sub-cultures, but we are still far away from what New York has to offer. While new styles and fashions are developed in New York, London and Paris, the Moscovites still copy… mainly from London (even in fashion). What Moscow has to offer, are a few overstyled posh clubs, which have no lack of money but a big lack of taste, especially in terms of style and music. Only a handful of clubs and bars are different and somewhat comparable to NYC or any other Metropolis. Of course there are a lot of alternative venues which cover anything from punk, ska, hip hop, indy and so on, but I am talking about the real cool bars and clubs you’d find in New York.

One more (and its probably my last) argument. Sure, I can go out and buy groceries all night long (as I can in NYC), but most of the shops close between 9 and 10 PM (talking about boutiques etc), like in New York. And yes, I can still find some after hour party in Moscow, sometime early morning, at a time, when other people get up and go to work. So what is the difference? In New York, I can go out any week day and find some decent party. Sure, its not easy on a Sunday, Monday or Tuesday, but its possible, because the city really never sleeps. Its hard to find anything in Moscow at any of these days. The nightlife starts Thursday and it ends Sunday at noon. All that is left for people like me, is a gay night or some fashionable youngsters, which squad a 300 year old wine cellar with a sound-system (the local paper Afisha called it the coolest thing in Moscow, these days).

Long story short. Moscow is not New York and it will probably never become the Big Apple. Its wishful thinking and the typical Russian big mouth based on their exaggerated patriotism. Of course the author of the Telegraph article was not Russian, but it seems to me someone was taking her around and telling here ever and ever again, ho cool Moscow is and how much better it is than anything else out there in the world. Again, sure Moscow is exciting, but its not comparable with New York. Probably not even with London, Madrid or Paris in terms of its nightlife.

As long as we don’t get a large mix of living sub-cultures, this city will not change and become as cool and alive as New York. There are creative sub-cultures in Moscow my critics may say. Yes you are right. A few hundred in a 15 mio people city. And hey, please don’t call a 2 year old “new rave” movement, a style that is dead in the rest of Europe for over a year, a living sub-culture. Russians need to find themselves. They need to develop an identity. It is, what got lost with the collapse of the communism and this vacuum was never filled. Today, Russians are living Sex In the City and Cashmere Mafia, because they think that this is the real deal. Where else would you find girls that prostitute themselves (we are talking about sex for money), so they can go and buy themselves that Prada bag or even more pervert, pay for cheap plastic surgery. This is not only a phenomenon among women. Even guys live the American dream to the fullest. Russians are trying to find themselves and as long as they will have found a clear definition of what it means to be a Russian or a Muscovite, they will copy from New York and London. What they really need is something on their own. Designers like Dennis Simachev are paving the way, but even Simachev was influenced by Gangsters and Hip Hop developing one of his last collections and the advertising to it. New York is greeting over the Atlantic again …

Don’t get me wrong. I love this city. I have lived long in New York and I miss it, but at this point I chose to stay here. Its fun to live in Moscow and see the city change so quickly. Moscow has a energy and dynamic that is similar to New York. The music scene is one of the drivers and slowly we are starting to see the existing and new sub-cultures growing. There is a lot of creative potential, in Moscow, but I’d say even more out in the Russian regions. I am very happy that I can witness this special time and the growing of a new Russia, which is torn back and forth between the West and its Middle Asian roots. Its also torn back and forth between its great history and a modern fast moving and consuming future.

By the way, here is another site of mine, where I showcase music that is hip in Moscow. You wont find what is played in Moscow’s posh clubs, but it will give you an idea what else is out there. There is also lots of Music from Russian DJs and producers.